Mobile Menu

  • Home
  • Recipes
  • BBQ
  • Grills
  • Desserts
    • Drinks
  • Tips & Tricks
    • How To
  • Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Spicy Salty Sweet

Your Guide About Cooking & Recipies

  • Home
  • Recipes
  • BBQ
  • Grills
  • Desserts
    • Drinks
  • Tips & Tricks
    • How To

Papa John’s Pizza Sauce Recipe for Your Late Night Pizza Cravings

May 21, 2022 //  by Leah Greenstein//  Leave a Comment

Papa John’s pizza sauce has one interesting recipe. Papa John’s pizza lovers have been looking everywhere to get the sauce recipe. This sauce is sweet and gravy-like and the recipe is unique. 

As it appears, there are several ways to create the sauce at home. Every recipe is distinct from the others. However, we tried to provide an identical sauce to Papa John’s. 
Don’t worry, it’s easy to follow these instructions. Won’t take you much time to recreate your favorite pizza sauce.

papa john's pizza sauce
Source: food
  • Level: Easy
  • Serving Portion: 1 cup 
  • Preparing Time: 10 minutes
  • Cooking Time: 20 minutes
  • Total time: 30 minutes

Nutritional Fact (1 cup): 

Calories 34
Total Fat.7g
Saturated Fat.3g
Cholesterol 0mg
Protein1.4g

Ingredient List For the Pizza Sauce

  • 1 can tomato puree (10 3/4 oz.)
  • 1 cup of water
  • 1 tablespoon of sugar
  • 1 teaspoon extra virgin olive oil
  • a quarter-teaspoon of lemon juice
  • 1⁄4 teaspoon salt
  • 1⁄4 teaspoon oregano
  • 1⁄8 teaspoon basil
  • 1⁄8 teaspoon thyme
  • 1⁄8 teaspoon garlic powder

Step-by-Step Instruction For Making the Sauce-

Making Papa John’s pizza sauce doesn’t take much effort. You’ll be relieved to learn that it’s fairly simple to create. All you have to do now is follow the directions precisely.

So let’s make this delicious sauce- 

Step 1 of 3: Mix the Ingredients 

Papa John uses sweet ripe tomatoes. You can find them in the store under different brands. 

First, pour your tomato puree into a pan. You can get tomato puree easily in one of the stores. If not, you can also use fresh tomatoes. In that case, blend the tomatoes in a blender. 

However, make sure there are no lumps. This sauce needs to be smooth. 

make tomato puree
Source: Dreamstime.com

Now add water to make the puree or sauce more liquid. Also add sugar, olive oil, lemon juice, salt, oregano, basil, thyme, and garlic powder to it. 

Step 2 of 3: Cook the Sauce

Taste the smooth tomato puree. If it’s not sweet, feel free to add sugar to your taste while cooking. Papa john’s sauce generally tastes sweet. 

cook the sauce
Source: NYT cooking

Pour the mixture into a saucepan. Place it on a medium heat setting. Reduce the heat when the sauce begins to boil. The sauce should then be simmered for 15 to 20 minutes on low heat.

Step 3 of 3: Ready to Serve 

After cooking the sauce, cool it down. Then it’s ready to be smeared on the pizza. You can change the taste by increasing salt or sugar to your preference. 

spread pizza sauce
Source: RecipeTin Eats

So, this is all about papa john pizza’s sauce recipe. 

Storing the Sauce

Got some leftover sauce? You don’t have to waste it. Freeze for up to three months in advance in a Ziploc bag. 

Before you want to use the sauce, defrost overnight and microwave in 30-second increments. Or you can melt it in a small saucepan until it’s smooth. 

storing the sauce
Source: Leite’s Culinaria

Pizza sauce may be kept in the fridge for 5–7 days. And keep the temperatures between 35 and 40 degrees Fahrenheit. However, if stored correctly at 0°F in the fridge, the sauce can last up to three months. 

Similarly, sauce purchased from an opened store lasts between 7 and 14 days. It depends on the preservative packaging. 

Well, that was all. Now Your pizza sauce is ready. Enjoy your pizza with this delicious sauce.

Some Important Tips-

We already stated that the recipe is easy to follow. But you might still have some confusion regarding the recipe. That’s why we are going to give you some tips- 

What’s The Secret To A Good Homemade Sauce? 

You may either boil the tomatoes for a very short period. Alternatively, let them simmer for at least 40 minutes to make a tasty tomato sauce. Since they only start to discharge their acid juices after approximately 10 minutes. And it takes at least half an hour for them to dissipate. 

How To Make Tomato Sauce Taste More Flavorful?

Using a little butter to sauté your vegetables at the beginning and a couple of teaspoons. In the end, it gives your sauce a softness and depth of flavor. Add 1/2 to 1 cup fresh chopped basil to the sauce after it’s done. Toss in 2 tsp oregano, chopped, or 1-2 tsp dried oregano at the start of the cooking process.

Why Should You Sprinkle Sugar In The Sauce? 

The reason for adding a teaspoon of sugar into a boiling tomato sauce is simple. Sugar reduces the acidity of the tomatoes, resulting in a more balanced sauce. The acid content varies greatly depending on the freshness of the tomatoes. It also changes if they are canned.

Now you know what ingredients Papa John uses in his special pizza sauce. Cook the sauce and let us know how you liked it! 

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Leah Greenstein
Leah Greenstein
Leah Greenstein is a passionate food blogger who has dedicated her life to sharing her love for cooking with the world. Growing up in a family of foodies, Leah was introduced to the joys of cooking at a very young age. Her mother, a professional chef, instilled in her a deep appreciation for the art of cooking and the importance of using high-quality ingredients.
Leah Greenstein
Latest posts by Leah Greenstein (see all)
  • How Long Does Vegan Butter Last? Mystery Solved - January 9, 2024
  • How Long Does Vegan Mayo Last - January 2, 2024
  • From Pot to Plate: How Long Does Vegan Chili Last in The Fridge? - December 26, 2023

Category: Recipes

Related Posts

You may be interested in these posts from the same category.

Photo of a chef in the process of making chorizo

Is Chorizo Made from Lymph Nodes – (+ An Exclusive Recipe!)

Can You Use Peanut Oil for Baking

Can You Use Peanut Oil for Baking – Cake Recipe Included!

summer sausage with a chef's hat

Is Summer Sausage Cooked? +(Age Old Recipe!)

Sides for Italian Chicken

Sides for Italian Chicken – #Top 8 Recommendations

caseys pizza recipe

Casey’s Breakfast Pizza Recipe: Iowa Special

donatos pizza sauce recipe

Donatos Pizza Sauce A.K.A The Simplest Pizza Sauce Ever!

bubba gump lobster butter sauce recipe

Bubba Gump Lobster Butter Sauce Recipe: A Little Taste of Heaven

bubba gump remoulade sauce recipe

The Finger Licking Bubba Gump Remoulade Sauce Recipe

ight and fluffy icing

Win Your Party Dessert With Mouth Watering Costco Frosting Recipe

papa gino's pizza dough recipe

Taste The Best Pizza With Papa Gino’s Pizza Dough Recipe

lynwood cafe pizza recipe

Lynwood Cafe Pizza Recipe For Bar Pizza Lovers

new haven pizza dough recipe

New Haven Pizza Dough Recipe: Special Thin Crust Version

Previous Post: «lynwood cafe pizza recipe Lynwood Cafe Pizza Recipe For Bar Pizza Lovers
Next Post: How To Patina A Knife With Vinegar how to patina a knife with vinegar»

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Our Favorite Recipes

Photo of a chef in the process of making chorizo

Is Chorizo Made from Lymph Nodes – (+ An Exclusive Recipe!)

Is Chorizo Made from Lymph Nodes – (+ An Exclusive Recipe!)
Can You Use Peanut Oil for Baking

Can You Use Peanut Oil for Baking – Cake Recipe Included!

Can You Use Peanut Oil for Baking – Cake Recipe Included!
summer sausage with a chef's hat

Is Summer Sausage Cooked? +(Age Old Recipe!)

Is Summer Sausage Cooked? +(Age Old Recipe!)
Sides for Italian Chicken

Sides for Italian Chicken – #Top 8 Recommendations

Sides for Italian Chicken – #Top 8 Recommendations

Recent Posts

How Long Does Vegan Butter Last? Mystery Solved

January 9, 2024

How Long Does Vegan Mayo Last

January 2, 2024

From Pot to Plate: How Long Does Vegan Chili Last in The Fridge?

December 26, 2023

Behind The Scenes: What Is Vegan Beef Made Of?

December 22, 2023

What Is Vegan Milk? 10 Best Vegan Milks With Their Benefits

December 21, 2023

Footer

“Every Day Is Another Chance To Get Stronger, To Eat Better, To Live Healthier, And To Be The Best Version Of You.”

Browse Categories

  • BBQ
  • Buying Guide
  • Comparison
  • Desserts
  • Drinks
  • Grills
  • How To
  • Is It Keto
  • Is It Vegan
  • Recipes
  • Reviews
  • Tips & Tricks

Site Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Earning Disclosure

Copyright © 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Contents by SpicySaltySweet.com
SpicySaltySweet.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.